In the preceding two posts, I have argued that there is little convincing evidence that shamans outside the extended culture area of the Upper Amazon have ever used hallucinogens in their shamanic work; and, in the immediately preceding post, I argued against the belief that shamans in Siberia used the fly agaraic mushroom Amanita muscaria for shamanizing.
There is also, I believe, little evidence for the shamanic use of psychoactive plants or mushrooms among the indigenous peoples of North America. As among the Khoryaks, non-shamans may attempt to emulate shamans by using psychoactive plants or mushrooms that shamans themselves do not use. For example, among the Chumash and other indigenous peoples in south central California, it can be important to acquire a dream helper, not just for shamans but for ordinary people as well: falcon helps gamblers, bobcat can help hunters, otter can make one a good swimmer, roadrunner helps midwives. Sometimes a dream helper appears in an ordinary dream; this is especially true of shamans, whose powers first appear in dreams during childhood. Conversely, to obtain a dream helper, common people rely heavily on Datura, which plays only a marginal role in the acquisition of shamanic power.
 |
| Keewaydinoquay Peschel |
There are similar problems with the claimed fly agaric use by shamans among the Anishinaabeg — often called the Ojibwe — of the Great Lakes area. The claim, first put forward by R. Gordon Wasson in 1978, rests entirely upon the testimony of a single person, an Anishinaabe herbalist and university-trained ethnobotanist named Keewaydinoquay Peschel. She claimed that she herself had been initiated into the shamanic use of the mushroom, and had herself used the mushroom three to five times a year for the past fifty years. She prepared a birch bark scroll containing a legend of how the mushroom came to the Anishinaabeg, which, Wasson said, evidenced its shamanic use.
There are some significant problems with this claim. There is no description of fly agaric use in any detailed ethnography of Anishinaabeg shamanism. When she first met Wasson, Keewaydinoquay apparently was living a solitary and unhappy life, spending much of her time alone on an isolated island; in any event, it is difficult to say to what extent she was, at that time, integrated into Anishinaabeg culture.
 |
| R. Gordon Wasson |
Further, Keewaydinoquay admitted that many Anishinaabeg were in fact strongly opposed to the consumption of fly agaric; indeed, her own revered teacher of herbalism, a woman named Nodjimahkwe, apparently knew about the mushrooms and prohibited her student from eating them. Moreover, versions of the legend told by other Anishinaabeg differ substantially from that given by Keewaydinoquay, including versions that prohibit the eating of any mushrooms at all.
Indeed, the mushroom legend itself, even as retold by Keewaydinoquay, contains little that would connect its use to shamanizing. The story tells how the Anishinaabeg discovered the mushrooms, and points out that those who use the mushroom are happy and pure, while those who do not are worried and unhappy. Although the mushroom reveals the supernatural and other knowledge to those who use it, the story provides no reason to believe that those who reportedly used the mushroom were shamans in any sense.
Further doubt is cast on the claim by the fact that Wasson and Keewaydinoquay were, apparently, lovers, or at least enmeshed in a highly charged personal relationship — one that seems, from her letters, to have been deeply important to Keewaydinoquay. And both derived ancillary benefits from this relationship: Wasson helped Keewaydinoquay obtain a doctorate in anthropology, a teaching position, and the publication of her writings on ethnomycology by the Harvard Botanical Museum; Keewaydinoquay gave Wasson an apparently idiosyncratic account of Anishinaabeg hallucinogen use that happened to be consistent with his theories. In the absence of confirmatory evidence, it is probably fair to view this account with caution.
- Previous Post: Hallucinogens in Siberia
- Next Post: The Tragedy of Maria Sabina
- More Articles Related to: Sacred Plants, Shamanism
Once again, syncretism and availability of ceremonies is good. However people forget how and where the first nations ceremonies came to be. The Anashinabe have the Mide lodge and the little boy water drum, cedar and rattle. And their medicine society is called the Midewiwin
There are people in the plains and northern tribes that have pseudo Yuwipi ceremonies and bring specific plants to ceremony that the spirits come to see. When they show up the person running the ceremony makes the audience believe they are there for him, when in reality they have come to see the plant. Pretty clever! It also shows some degree of understanding of ceremonial use of certain plants and calling songs.
The further north one ventures, the less use of many other “mystical” plants that one sees. Ceremonies involve (to the sadness of those looking for the pink neon buffalo) water, tobacco, corn, squash, sage, maple syrup and a few unlucky salmons. However in urban populations is not uncommon to find chapters of the Native American church. This is happening a lot in places like Ecuador, Chile, Bolivia, Colombia, Mexico and Brasil as well. It is common to have traditional elders recognize that there’s god medicine in the NAC and the Yage drinking, but to also remind people that their own ways are there for them as well.
How can you claim the geographic limitation of entheogen use to South/central America when there has been continous use of iboga in western africa by pygmy tribes since neolithic times?
As far as I know — and I would be grateful for any reference that proves me wrong — iboga use is limited to a specific group — the Bwiti religion in Gabon. More important, the question is not whether people use entheogens all over the world. There is no doubt that they do, for all kinds of reasons — personal exploration, recreational inebriation, initiatory ordeals. The question I am asking is whether these plants and fungi are used for *shamanizing*, and I still have not seen evidence that persuades me to abandon the idea that *shamanic* use of psychoactive plants and fungi are uniquely part of a culture area radiating out from the Upper Amazon. Here is an example: ayahuasca is used in several new religious movements in Brazil, but in none of them would I consider its use to be shamanic. Believe me, my mind is not closed; that’s why I put my thoughts out there on this blog. Please, if you have any references that show iboga used for shamanizing — the way, say, ayahuasca is used in Western Amazonia — let me know.
As far as I know the modernised Bwiti cult which is often syncretised with christianity in Gabon, is a more recent adoption of Iboga for religious ritual/healing by the full sized african people of the locality.
The original usage of the entheogen in that region was exclusively by the pygmy tribes who still live their traditional hunter gatherer existence in the equatorial rain forests of Gabon & Cameroon. They follow the traditional animistic Bwiti religion.
The plant is worshipped as “the source of spiritual knowledge and as a tool for accessing the wisdom of the ancestors”. They have their shamans that use the plant for healing, sorcery and communicating with the dead, but also make general use of it for initiations ceremonies.
There is limited information about their way of life available on the net, but I first learned of them via an fascinating BBC program called ‘Tribe’, a documentary that follows Bruce Parry as he undegoes a traditional bwiti initiation with iboga in a Babonga pygmy village.
Check out the bbc site :-
http://www.bbc.co.uk/tribe/tribes/babongo/
Mr. Beyer,
Your article of my spiritual teacher is fraught with fiction. Kee was not ‘solitary and unhappy’ as you say–she was surrounded by many family members an hundreds of students–she delighted in sharing her herbal knowledge with her students. You didn’t even know her. I did for many years. It is true that Kee knew about this mushroom and wrote about it. I never knew her when she did all you said she supposedly did–she did not concentrate on that plant in all the years I knew her. That is pure supposition/invention on your part. Please do not type false things of honored elders. Its just not a good thing.
J.Lorenzen
Apparently you knew Keewaydinoquay only after her relationship with Wasson was over. If, as you say, she did not then concentrate on the mushroom, I see nothing inconsistent with my account — that her claims of Anishinaabeg shamanic mushroom use were accommodations to Wasson’s obsession. There is no doubt that she was a fascinating woman and dedicated herbalist, and I am delighted to learn that she found happiness later in her life. But that does nothing to alleviate my skepticism about the use of Amanita muscaria by Anishinaabeg shamans.
Dear Mr. Beyer,
Thank you for your thoughtful comments questioning Peschel’s legitimacy as a source for Chippewa (Ojibwe) cultural knowledge and her integration into local Native culture. Indeed, she avoided local Indian people as much as we avoided her. Her daughter still lives in the region, and denies any Native identification. Anishinaabe cultural insiders question even Peschel’s apparently-manufactured linguistic terms. Her greatest claim to fame in her adopted homeland, northwest Lower Michigan’s Leelanau County, is that she allegedly led to the inadvertent poisoning death (by ingestion of wild mushrooms) of one of her enthusiastic young non-Native followers while on a field trip to Lake Michigan’s Beaver Island. The island was formerly the home of several aboriginal families who were forced onto the mainland to make way for a burgeoning population of affluent non-Native “cottagers.” Peschel and her non-Native followers continue to promote cute stereotypes about the region’s indigenous population; this in turn has contributed to rampant cultural appropriation, morbid racism, and an off-reservation unemployment rate among Native Americans in excess of 99%. Peschel’s othercultural impersonation and teachings contribute to the ongoing dimunization of Native people and substitute fiction for fact. There is no place for this in science, in credible literature, or in functional cultural intercourse.
At this time of division in the US between the cultures of the red states and the blue states and within them of “conservative” and “liberal,” it may be a time for Native knowledge to be shared with non-Natives as Keewaydinoquay did, however threatening to or inadequately representing Anishinaabe culture. Hert sharing was to strengthen our common ties to the earth. Non-natives should, as one Native elder said (and others agreed), realize that they are home. Keewaydinoquay assisted that process with great presence and eloquence. May she rest in peace.
I am not sure why I am rejoining an old controversy from which I have nothing to gain and which does not hold any interest for me any longer. But I certainly would like to set part of the record straight. I was a friend of Wasson’s for a very long time, a period which included the entire Kee episode. I was then a graduate student in Anthropolgy at Yale, and it happened that Claude Lévi-Strauss brought our attention to a portion of the Jesuit Relations which described Amanita muscaria use by the shamans of the Anishinaabeg. Hence, my involvement in the project and, moreover, that excerpt shows that Kee was not the sole source of this information. I must certainly assert that the statement: “the fact that Wasson and Keewaydinoquay were, apparently, lovers, or at least enmeshed in a highly charged personal relationship” is entirely false, or, if such strong feelings existed, they were entirely one-sided. In fact, Wasson was so distressed by his experience when he went to the island the first time, that he told me he could never go back there again. So, he asked me to investigate there further, as the account in the Jesuit Relations had not yet been verified, or rather, fully examined. My account of what happened is on a tape that you can hear at http://www.dstretch.com/Kee/index.html until, or unless, it disappears as most things on the web do. I told the simple truth to the audience in San Francisco. I hold no opinion about its shamanic character. I am astounded that it could be thought that Wasson and Kee could be “lovers”. It was utterly out of character for an old and infirm man, suffering from recurring strokes, very upset at the encounter, and totally absorbed in the life of the mind, could behave that way. It is, in fact, disgusting to claim that, and whoever started this canard should be deeply ashamed. She was an “informant”, pure and simple. That he helped her in her life was only normal generosity – or, if you prefer, reciprocity.
One thing about the mushrooms I ate on the island that has never been told, and has bothered me since, is that it was so dark at the time that I could not see what the mushroom was; I could not identify it. I suppose that will make the skeptics happy. Actually I hope that this entire subject will be consigned to the dustbin of history. I want no more part of it.
Hi Reid,
The recording that you link to is on my website. I hope it lasts for a little while.
There is information about Gordon and Kee, but I couldn’t find much about you. Could you fill in some details?
Your part in that presentation was fascinating. I am sorry you feel so negatively about the subject. Could you share why?
Contact me at DStretch “at” prodigy.com.
Regards,
Jon
Sorry, should be DStretch “at” prodigy.net